https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=64176
--- Comment #6 from Patrick Ohly <patrick.ohly(a)gmx.de> ---
(In reply to comment #5)
> > My work-in-progress branch will eventually add the option
to
> > set collation types for some fields, for example to set "phonebook"
> > collation on given_name and family_name, the configuration looks like this:
> >
> > CollationFields=family_name,phonebook:given_name,phonebook
>
> I doubt that this will be practical. Choosing the "phonebook" collation
only
> makes sense in some locales. Who decides to add "phonebook" in the EDS
> source config and when?
>
> What happens if the user changes the locale from one where "phonebook" is
> right to one where it is not?
>
> IMHO, overriding the default collation belongs into an additional env
> variable that then gets changed together with the LANG/LC_ env variables.
>
> In the meantime, EDS should hard-code sane defaults for several
"relevant"
> locales.
The idea is that "phonebook" collation is a preference that is either
available under the current locale, or not.
When a locale change has been detected, the sort keys will be generated
under the "phonebook" collation of the new locale... this will fallback
to the default ICU rules for the given locale if "phonebook" tailoring
is not available.
So the "phonebook" keyword is just a hint that this field is meant to be sorted
according to phone book rules if applicable? Is there value in having to
configure this, instead of hard-coding it for each field? Well, perhaps,
because then it can be enabled for other fields, too, without having to modify
the source code.
I don't see much value in being able to turn off "phonebook" for name
fields,
though.
How would this work for Pinyin? In other words, what would
CollationFields=family_name,pinyin:given_name,pinyin do when switching from
zn_CN (where Pinyin is expected) to de_DE (where phone book is execpted)?
It looks to me that "phonebook" in EDS should be merely a flag for certain
fields which inside EDS gets translated into a suitable (hard-coded?!)
collation per current locale (ICU "phonebook" in de and fi, ICU
"pinyin" in
Chinese locales). See also bug #64173.
Note that Pinyin may require additional work, see bug #64173 comment #3.
--
You are receiving this mail because:
You are on the CC list for the bug.
You are the assignee for the bug.