Yep, the mystery is how does Nokia differentiate from tasks and todos if they are stored together? So you can get data from the server for todos and notes? I thought I could not. Maybe you can provide a separate sync for todo and notes separately and send me the dump message(which is the *.xml file under the same folder as the html logs, if you have set the log level large enough). Sure, the client can even resume from where it got interrupted. For example: if the your client issues delete to server and failed in the middle, it just leads to a unsynchronized and resumeable state, it will get synced correctly next time. Even if there is something more disastrous happened, SyncEvolution has a snapshot for your data before sync and after sync, you can restore your data manually. Best Regards, Congwu From: Suyog [mailto:suyog@ovi.com] Sent: Tuesday, October 27, 2009 11:03 PM To: Chen, Congwu Subject: Re: RE: RE: SyncEvolution Bug 3182 - support ovi.com (Nokia sync service) Hi, I also was able to Sync Calendar , your guess was correct I was using ./EventTasks/Tasks earlier. For Syncing Todo, what i think is todos are stores as part of calendar in Nokia Phones. If calendar entries are stored as ./EventTask/Task, same way may be for todo ./EventTask/To-do? I tried this and please see attached screenshots/logs for result. We need to confirm this from Nokia. As I understand that these entries have to to perfect, and in correct case, i.e. EventTask may not be same as eventtask. Opensync does sync Todo entries in Nokia to Tasks in Evolution. so I target should be ./Tasks in Evolution as there is nothing like "todo" in Evolution. I was not able to Sync Notes with OpenSync as I mentioned in last mail that in Evo2-sync plugin of Open sync, we can only specify 3 categories, cotacts, calendar, tasks. I think following should be Target & Source. OVI.com Evolution Notes ./Note/Unfiled Memo To-do ./EventTask/To-do Tasks If you see my log, it shows that for todos and notes also data is coming from server and getting rejected. I was asking for Fail-safe option, in case there is Network disconnection how local/server deletes will be handled? Do we have any chance to recover data? Right Now I think deletes happen first then fetch. I will try building OpenSync 0.39 again but it will be great if we can have deb package. I trying to contact OpenSync Developers but no reply. Let me know how it goes. Best Regards, Suyog ----- Original message ----- From: "Chen, Congwu" <congwu.chen(a)intel.com&gt; To: Suyog <suyog(a)ovi.com&gt; Subject: RE: RE: SyncEvolution Bug 3182 - support ovi.com (Nokia sync service) Date: Tue, 27 Oct 2009 13:00:06 +0800 Suyog, My finding is: Calendar actually works (no “server reject access” error, maybe you put a wrong uri? ./EventTask/Tasks not ./EventTasks/Tasks And without a server side uri for Todos, we cannot differentiate calendars and tasks. You mentioned Nokia phones syncing todos with Evolution tasks, that’s correct. While you also mentioned Nokia phones don’t have defined todos separately, I am confused here. If Nokia phones have todos and syncing with Ovi todos successfully, that’s a good point, we may dig further to find what syncing uri it is using.. If Nokia phones don’t have todos, then what’s the usage of the Todos in the ovi web page? For memos, you are correct, content rejection. Nokia must have some different format/interpretation of their notes. Can you sync from your phone with opensync for memos? If yes, maybe you can give me an opensync dump message. http://bugzilla.moblin.org/show_bug.cgi?id=3182#c7 Ah, what do you mean here? In SyncML, if client issues “delete” cmds to server, server can accept it showing “server deleted or reject it with “server rejected”. What problems you get in building it? Following is a guide for building and installing libsyncml (part of opensync), the rest part should be mostly the same. You can have a try. https://libsyncml.opensync.org/wiki/obex-guide We have not tested it specifically but we are testing with latest debian testing and we have a compatibility mode for evolution-data-server related apis. Therefore I am optimistic about this. Best Regards , Congwu From:Suyog [mailto:suyog@ovi.com] Sent: Monday, October 26, 2009 5:02 AM To: Chen, Congwu Subject: Re: RE: SyncEvolution Bug 3182 - support ovi.com (Nokia sync service) Hi, I tried playing around config options in SyncEvolution and also did few tests with OVI sync. I have kept backup of my PIM data, as I am doing tests with my actual account, Back saved me a lot. After trying with many changes in config, I am not able to sync Calendar and Todo. Same error as below mail. log in succeeded, but server refuses access - contact server operator In GUI , I get message "Forbidden" for Calendar and Todo Sync. May be you can have a look again. Please note that in Nokia Phones , there is nothing defined separately for To-dos, somehow they are treated as part of Calendar( May be ./EventTasks/Tasks). Also as I use OpenSync to sync my phone over Bluetooth with Evolution, I noted that To-dos sync with Tasks in Evolution but Notes cant be Synced with Memo as evo2-sync plugin for Opensync doesn't support it. I used instructions at following link. http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=260676&page=17 For SyncEvolution, I think we are also facing similar issue, Notes are getting synced but being rejected by Evolution. Same happens when we try to create new memo and try to sync, we get server rejection. Hence basic issue I believe is the way Evolution and OVI/Nokia phones address Notes(Memos). You can check Opensync with with evo2-sync and syncml-obex-client plugins to understand how they handle Calendar and Todo items. Also I tried all 3 options , Merge, Delete local data and replace, Delete Server data and replace. All work very well with contacts, and with Memos , I get same rejections error but it deletes server data. Do we have any fail safe option now in case of server delete option? i.e if we use server data delete option. Could you please help me in getting latest Opensync? I wanted to test 0.39 version but I don't know how to build or install it. Well I am not programmer, I am chemical Engineer :-), just Tech Enthusiast. hence I need help when it comes to building apps from source in linux. I have done few simple apps build but not with much dependency. Let me know if you need more details, screenshots or logs. I feel really great that we made good progress. Best Regards, Suyog -------------------------------------------------------------- Ovi Mail: Easy setup in minutes http://mail.ovi.com